Image description
Published on

REPOSITORY REPORT - AmericanAncestors.org

Image description
AMERICAN ANCESTORS (online website for the New England Historic Genealogical Society) has many searchable collections, a list of which is too long to detail here.  For our purpose of pinning down death dates and locations of Northborough's founding fathers, I searched only the death and probate record indexes for the 39 "Heads of Families" previously documented as residing in the town in 1744.  The reason for choosing those specific names and that particular year is to establish a baseline of which families were known to have lived there during our research period of 1727-1749.  The plan is to subsequently identify their family members' death dates and locations during that period as well.   Any deaths occurring during the research period will be evaluated as a possible burial at the Brigham Street Burial Ground. 
Colonial records can be difficult to locate for a variety of reasons.  First and foremost, it must be understood that the recording of deaths was customary but that many of the early paper records have since been lost to fire or neglect.  Many of the death records found in the Massachusetts Town Records collection come from a variety of sources, including original town records, church records, and gravestone transcriptions.  The NEHGS database is considered a finding aid, not a source, because the abstracted information given is only a summary taken from the original document [and not the information in its original form].  Therefore, for the wills and probate records, I still need to locate the originals and transcribe them before citing the evidence.   As the Massachusetts Town Records collection can be viewed as PDFs (pictures), I considered viewing those images the same as reading the original books and will properly cite the evidence from them.  [Although the records books are not defined as true original death records, they are likely to be the closest I get in some cases.]

Name variations, misspelling of names, and multiple relatives with the same name can all present challenges when trying to locate a correct record for a specific person.  As I mentioned in my last post, the name "James Eager" was used over three generations in the same family, including siblings.  A closer look at that family illustrates a common naming pattern for families, which is to reuse a name for a child born after a sibling with that name had died.  My favorite name variation example is that of "Joshua Townsend," also known as "Joshua Dowsing."  Put on your best colonial British accent, speak both surnames quickly, and you'll see why!  Finally, phonetic spelling is very subjective and frequently resulted in records under different names for many of the people I researched.

For determining death dates, I was able to find most of the proprietors in the series of Massachusetts Town Vital Records compiled by Franklin Rice in the early 1900's.  In other cases, the NEHGS index listed a will or probate record indicating an approximate year of death.  When a probate court record was given, I made note of the record number for finding the original document at the Massachusetts State Archives.  On Ancestry.com, I used the death records to source cite a proprietor's death and noted where original probate and will records existed and still need to be consulted before source citing. 

A few of the men could not be located in either the Massachusetts Town Death Records or the Probate Record Index.  For the purposes of this specific database search, I noted the results as having returned no information.  However, on the Ancestry.com tree page for those men, there is evidence found in other sources providing clues as to where and when those men may have lived and died.  None of the men in this category had an indicated death date during the research period. 

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

Image description
PROPRIETORS WHO DIED DURING THE RESEARCH PERIOD 1727-1749
After performing record searches in the American Ancestors database for probate and death records for each of the 39 original town proprietors of 1744, it was found that only 3 died during the research period.  Of these, Joseph Wheeler has already been documented as a burial at the Brigham Street Burial Ground.  The Tomlin family members, father and son, both died before or near the time that the Brigham site was closed. 

FURTHER RESEARCH
Additional information about where the 2 Tomlin proprietors were buried may be found in the Westborough and Northborough church records.  Copies of the Westborough Church records are at the Westborough Public Library and the First Church of Northborough records are in the archives of the American Antiquarian Society.  Gravestone transcriptions for the 2 towns' colonial burial grounds need to be located. 

Original probate and will records are archived at the Massachusetts State Archives.  Names of living family members, inventory of estate, and personal information (including burial directions) may be found in the documents.

Reverend Parkman's diary entries may also provide information about the men's last days. 
FINDING AID:
American Ancestors (website for the New England Historic Genealogical Society), www.americanancestors.org.

SOURCES:
Kent, Josiah Coleman.  Northborough History.  Newton, Massachusetts: Garden City Press, 1921.

Vital Records of Westborough, Massachusetts, to the End of the Year 1849.  Worcester, Mass.: Franklin P. Rice. 1903.
Published on

SITE VISIT IMPRESSIONS

Today's weather?  No snow on the ground, ground dry, skies sunny...a perfect day to walk the Brigham Street Burial Ground since beginning this project.  It seemed like the perfect opportunity to visit the site, armed with a sketch of its history and of who may be interred there.  With the objectivity of a researcher, but my personal curiosity of getting a new impression of the place, I headed over and started walking a grid.

And that is where the experience got tricky. 

Having read about burial customs of the times, having found a witness's documentation of more burials in addition to the 4 still there, and understanding the family and neighbor relationships that existed about 1730, I "saw" so much more in that patch of land than I ever would have thought. 

The parcel was cleaned up and cleared before the winter, so the ground was completely exposed and easily walked.  The Holloway/Wheeler family members are still where I remembered, of course.  Each of the parallel and west-facing graves is still well-marked with head and footstone, the roughly 5ft by 2ft mound between the stones smattered with large rocks among the moss.  This time, however, I stood back away from that small section in order to really observe the larger area nearby with a new perspective.  And that is when it struck me.  There are even more groupings of parallel patches of stones, some mounded and some sunken.  There are even a few parallel sunken spots near the rear of the parcel.  All these are not news, of course, as the observations have been made by others in the past.  For me, however, to have a researched to date a count of close to 20 possible burials and to be able to count at least that number of visible marked spots left me stunned, frankly.  I was also saddened by the understanding that they have been long since forgotten, except by those who maintain the property to keep it clean and mowed.

There have been several efforts in the past to identify those buried there.  My very non-scientific hope is that the advances made in technology over the last several decades, coupled with the advances of the information age, can shed new light on just what the story is in this interesting old place.  And which of the brave founding families should be remembered and honored. 
Published on

ONLINE FAMILY TREE (Ancestry.com)

Image description
(Revised 4/1/2011)
As I discover the possible burials at Brigham Street Burial Ground, I post the working research notes (complete with documentation and notations) on Ancestry.com.  For subscribers to the site, the tree to view is listed as Early Northborough, MA Settlers.  My notations are fairly clear and if any life events do not have attached citations, it means that I have either yet to locate a source or the event is irrelevant to my project.  Finding aids and online databases are not cited as sources, but the clues they provide are detailed under the appropriate event in a profile's timeline; the original records will be located and transcribed during future research. 

Please bear in mind that I am primarily adding events from online sources to the Ancestry tree, partially due to the accuracy and convenience of copy-and-paste.  Offline, I am keeping additional notes and copies of records that may not make it to the public tree, at least for the time being.  Conflicting evidence for events are noted and will be resolved during future research.

As the focus of the research is to establish whether or not a particular person died during the period 1727-1750, the biographical information I post to the tree is only that which I evaluated as part of determining a person's date of death during those years.  (There are many more stories and details about the settlers and I hope to include them at a later date.)  Those persons who are "known" burials at Brigham Street can be quickly identified on the "List of All People" page with their names in all CAPS (example: "ADAM HOLLOWAY").  The "probable" names will have capitilized surnames only (example:  "Hannah OAKE").   "Possible"  names will be noted on their individual profile pages.  Those settlers found to have died before 1727 or after 1750 will have either a recorded death date or a note that they died outside the research period (example: "died after 1757 when last child was born.")

Finally, the town of record in any event closely follows the historical timeline of how the land was known at that time.  In other words, if a person lived in what is Northborough today their life events will be recorded on the tree as:

-  Marlborough (1660-1717)
-  Westborough (1717-1744)
-  Westborough Precinct 2 (1744-1766)
-  Northborough (after 1766)

ONLINE SOURCES

Image description

During the curent stage of the Brigham Street Burial Ground project, the publications and records I am researching are also available online through a variety of sites:
(1)  Ancestry.com has digitized histories and vital record compilations. 
(2)  American Ancestors (NEHGS site) has digital publications and records, in addition to those on Ancestry.com.
(3)  Google Books has many of the same digital publications as Ancestry.com, as well as other rare and limited release books. 
(4)  The Library of Congress has a selection of its holdings accessible online (see also The Internet Archive).
(5)  The Internet Archive has digital book uploads, comparable to Google Books, from a variety of institutions and users.

I use a combination of the above, along with hardcopies of the publications not available digitally, to document the evidence for the research.  Ideally, the original copies of any of the works and documents should be located and cited.  If you are interested in any of the sources I have accessed to date, they are listed on my SOURCES page.  Hardcopies can be ordered online through sites such as Amazon.com and rare/used booksellers. 

WORDS OF CAUTION

Image description
I have found that some uploaded digital books are of poor image quality or are simply OCR versions of scanned originals.  In both instances, material is either missing or illegible.  Therefore, I do not use anything except "exact copies" of the original texts as to stay true in my documentation.  (Note:  In the illustration to the right, the company that published this OCR copy sells a digital [PDF] exact copy of the original book for a fee and can be bought from them directly.)
Image description
When using the search function to locate names in digital books (basically PDF files), a problem arises when two or more people have the same name.  For example, "James Eager" of colonial Westborough is actually 4 different people.  Only by reading texts thoroughly and in chronological order can the confusion be avoided.  Additionally, using the history books in conjuction with vital records is imperative to evaluate a person's age and circumstance (living, married, or dead) at the time of a given event and whether or not it makes sense.
Note that not all information in history books and family genealogies is documented and should be used with discretion.  Family lore and local stories are often passed down through the ages like the "telephone game", where details get modified or added as the story gets retold.  Therefore, my goal is to find more than one independent and reliable source of evidence before classifying an event as probable.  Furthermore, known will be a very rare label, used only when an event is reported by an eyewitness. 

Image description
A final note of advice for using any publication (print or electronic) is you should read the work in its entirety before using its information for research.  Footnotes, endnotes, and appendices can contain corrections or clarifications to the text and must be considered before citing the evidence.  In my case, it wasn't until I reached the end of the Topographical and Historical Sketches of the Town of Northborough (Allen, 1826) that I found his "Errata" containing corrections to names, dates, and places.  Any information I cite will be noted as the corrected version.
Published on
Excerpt from Northborough History (Kent, 1921. p. 3-6)
"In 1744 there were thirty-seven families in the north part; and being situated at a distance of several miles from the main part of the town [of Westborough], they thought that they could get along much better if they should be permitted to manage their own affairs.  So, remembering what the west part of Marlborough [i.e. Westborough] had done in 1717, they drew up a petition, went down to Boston, and presented it to the Great and General Court. This petition asked that the north part of Westborough be made into a "distinct and separate precinct" of the town. The petition was granted on October 20, 1744.

Image description
...Having gained the objects of their desire, steps were immediately taken for the perfecting of a government for the new precinct.  Accordingly, all the inhabitants of the district were duly and legally warned to meet on the 15th day of November for that purpose.

This first precinct meeting was held at the home of Colonel William Holloway...This meeting was for purely organization purposes; and...marks the beginning of our town government.
...We have stated above that there were thirty-seven families in the north precinct at the time of its separation from the mother town...The list includes ...two young men who were not married at the time, but who were married shortly afterwards."
Picture
Published on
RECAP OF RESEARCH DONE TO DATE: 
The Brigham Street Burial Ground (Northborough, Mass.) was established in 1728 to accommodate burials for those families living in the "northern part"  of Westborough and was actively used until the First Church graveyard on Howard Street was established abt 1749.  As the beginning phase of any research project includes gathering "known" evidence, my first step was to visit the cemeteries and verify what could be "seen" as the jumping off point for evidence collection. 

While visible tombstones are an original source for evidence, additional documentation of deaths between 1728 and 1749 might provide evidence of other burials there.  Therefore, the next type of information I needed to locate what was either written by someone who witnessed the burials, or records of burials created close to the time they happened.  As I previously noted, the diary volumes of Reverend Ebenezer Parkman (see "Sources" page)  contain the most reliable information located to date; he either officiated, attended, or was informed of burials at that time. 


NEW RECORD SEARCHED:
Vital Records of Northborough, Massachusetts to the Year 1850 (Worcester, Mass.: Franklin P. Rice,1901) was the next source I evaluated.   Although Northborough was still known as "northern Westborough" during the period being researched (1727-1749) and was not incorporated until 1775,  I was able to find pre-revolutionary deaths included in the Northborough records.  That presented the theory that extra effort was taken to include deaths in the physical land area of Northborough, regardless of jurisdiction.  While not proof, there also seems to be a strong possibility that those "northern Westborough" deaths = "northern Westborough" burials.  (Quick reminder here: the Brigham Street Burial Ground was established so that "northern Westborough" families did not have to travel up to 6 miles south to bury their loved ones near the meeting house.)

Although the vital record book was published over 150 years after the first recorded death, the compiled information came from sources originally created close to the time of the actual deaths (church records, town records, tombstones, private records).  By definition, this derivative source (not the actual piece of paper the death was recorded on) is not as reliable as an entry in the archived diary, but the original records were nonetheless created with the noble intention of documenting deaths close to when occurred.  My goal was to match up the impartial early death records from Northborough with dated entries in Rev. Parkman's transcribed diary.  (NOTE: the original diary should be viewed during future research.)

The final step was to locate any burials for the recorded deaths [before 1750] at the Howard Street Old Burial Ground, whose opening abt 1750 facilitated the closing of Brigham Street Burial Ground.  Any of the burials not found at Howard Street would be added to the list of possible burials at the older Brigham Street site. 

RESEARCH RESULTS:

Image description
Vital Records of Northborough, Massachusetts to the Year 1850

Eager, James, s. James and Miriam, May 26, 1749 a. 1 d.
Eager, Joseph, s. James and Miriam, May 29, 1749, a. 4 d.
NOTE:  These twins were buried at the "new" Howard Street Burial Ground, est. 1749/50.

Fay, Hezekiah, s. Timothy and Lydia, Sept. 13, 1746.
Fay, Lydia, d. Timothy and Lydia, Sept. 14, 1746
Fay, Timothy, s. Timothy and Lydia, April 29, 1743
Fay, William, s. Timothy and Lydia, Sept. 13, 1746
NOTE: 
These Fay siblings died before the Howard Street site opened and during the years Brigham Street site was active.  There burials are not listed at Howard Street and will be added to the list of possible burials at Brigham Street. 

Image description
The Diary of Ebenezer Parkman (1703-1782):
First Part, Three Volumes in One (1719-1755).

1)  Entry for 12 September 1746:  "Hear of Several Deaths in our North Precinct." (p. 142)
NOTE:  While the Fay children are not specifically mentioned along with 2 Rice children's deaths, the fact that so many children died in one family, and at  the same time other children died, follows the logic of an epidemic affecting the very young.  The area to become modern Northborough was set apart from Westborough as "Second Precinct of Westborough" in 1744.

2)  No entry for April 1743. (Only the months of January and September are included for that year.)  This was about the time "northern Westborough" was organizing a partial separation from Westborough.

3)  No entry for 1749 (Northborough had already separated from Westborough for church matters as it had its own church and minister.)


SUMMARY OF RESEARCH:
The 2 Eager children that died in 1749 appear to be the first recorded deaths in the town that were buried at the Howard Street Burial Ground.  There was no other official burial site in the north section of Westborough (modern Northborough) other than the Brigham Street Burial Ground at the time of the Fay children's deaths. Therefore, it is possible that the 4 Fay children who died during the years of 1743-1746 were buried as a family group at the Brigham site, alongside the documented burial of their cousin, "CHILD Fay."

NEW TREES WITH 4 IDENTITIES ADDED:

Image description
The Fay siblings located in the death records were the cousins of one of "The Unidentified Children," Child Fay.  This not only gives us another puzzle piece for the list of potential burials, this piece SNAPS the two Fay families together as a "family group."




SOURCES:
Brigham Street Burial Ground (Northborough, Worcester County, Massachusetts; 360-380 Brigham Street).

Howard Street Old Burial Ground (Northborough, Worcester County, Massachusetts.

Parkman, Ebenezer.  The Diary of Ebenezer Parkman (1703-1782): First Part, three Volumes in One (1719-1755). Edited by Francis G. Walett. Worcester: American Antiquarian Society, 1974.

Vital Records of Northborough, Massachusetts to the End of the Year 1850
. Worcester, Mass.: Franklin P. Rice, 1901.
Published on
This week's research included establishing the historical event baseline to which all evidence can be compared.   For the next phase of research, which is to locate vital records (birth, marriage, and death) for "persons of interest", it is crucial to understand in what official town those Northborough ancestors would have been known to have lived during their lifetime.   

As illustrated in the timeline below, the land that was to eventually be incorporated as Northborough had several iterations after  settlement about 1660.  As population increased during the next century, the large area established as the Marlborough Plantation was eventually divided up into the following smaller towns:  Northborough, Westborough, Marlborough, Hudson, and Southborough.  
 
Picture
Published on
HOLLOWAY/WHEELER Family + HOLLOWAY Child = Family Group

There were two pieces of the puzzle that needed to be investigated:  

        (1)  The 4 known burials of the Holloway extended family
        (2)  The newly found burial of a Holloway child (from Rev. Ebenezer Parkman's August 1738 diary entry)

The shared surname indicated that there may have been a close familial relationship and that families did desire to be buried together. 

Further investigation found that the Holloway child was the grandchild of Adam Holloway (the oldest of the remaining stones in the Brigham Street Burial Ground).  Adam's son William had at least 8 children, all born before or during the years the Brigham Street burial site was officially active (1727-1749).  As for the exact identity of the child who is buried there, additional research needs to be done, specifically to document which children died on or before Aug 1738.  To date, I have a record of one childhood death, that of William Holloway, Jr. (1726-1727).


Identified Burials (in white)
Published on
This week has been spent researching the Who's Who of Adam Holloway's early colonial family.  Using various towns' birth, marriage, and death records in tandem with the town's published histories, I've uncovered a wonderfully large family full of intriguing stories.  There are promising lives lost to Indian terrorism, young love cut short by war, widows left to build new lives in new places...and the brave men that took risks to plant the seeds of our country's strength.   

While there are many more places to peek for clues to this family's adventures, the one little tidbit that keeps cropping up is how my modern life crosses their old paths every blessed day.  I found Adam's burial place quite out of curiosity, nothing else.  But I have also discovered that he and his family are a lot closer; they probably owned the land on which my house was built.  That can only mean one thing; the meadow I gaze across every morning with my cup of coffee and the nearby hillside I fall in love with all over again every foliage season has taken on another facet which can only be explained by Serendipity. 

The next time you see an old stone wall or a clearing in the woods, think of our early pioneers...and just imagine what is was like to be them.  Eye opening, really.